These women in India break the law to sell their eggs for IVF

MUMBRA, India — The afternoon sun shines on the woman in a commuter-town café, highlighting her almond-shaped eyes and pale skin, a look often sought after by couples who need an egg to have a baby.

“I have good eggs,” she laughs — good enough that she guesses she’s a biological mother to at least 30 children.

Producing multiple eggs isn’t easy on the human body. Typically a woman in her reproductive years will release one egg a month — it’s either fertilized or flushed out with her period.

But when H has a commission, she’ll inject herself with hormones for days to stimulate her ovaries to produce 20 to 30 eggs at a time. While she’s under anesthesia, a health worker inserts a long thin needle through the wall of H’s vagina to retrieve those eggs from her ovaries.

H says doctors who have extracted her eggs have told her that she typically produces about two dozen at a time and that they are high quality — that is, they’re more likely to be fertilized.

H says that, alongside her good looks, it’s why she’s in demand. She estimates she has undergone 30 retrievals in the past five years. Whether the number is correct or not, it’s clear that she does this regularly.

If each of those retrievals produced one live baby, she’d be a biological mother to at least 30 children. She thinks there are far more. She boasts: “If they’ve harvested 20 eggs from my body, you can assume 10 kids have popped out at least.”

Over the years, H has been paid a high of $800 for her eggs and a low of $280 for a yield of eggs. Even that amount is more than the monthly wage of most jobs in India.

Breaking the law to survive

It’s unclear how many women sell their eggs in India.

H says women like her hide in plain sight. She says, “There are so many who are literally running their houses on egg donation.”

Selling her eggs is how H has survived since she left her unhappy marriage and was left homeless. H’s ex-husband received custody of their two children, and she drifted into the port city of Mumbai. She had no way of paying rent, and she recalls a girlfriend telling her: “You are beautiful — you are young. Sell your eggs and get some money. I’ve done it. Lots of girls do it.”

H didn’t understand. She’d never been told the basics of reproduction. Her girlfriend said: “You are just providing a part of your body to another person, so they can have a baby.”

Why selling eggs became illegal

Critics say this illegal market exists because India radically constrained the supply of human eggs after the government passed laws in 2021 to regulate its wild-west fertility industry.

Couples, gay and straight, as well as single men and women began flocking to India around 2002, when the country allowed foreigners to access commercial surrogacy. That made India a one-stop shop for baby making: A person could obtain sperm, eggs, embryos, a surrogate — all for a fraction of the price in the United States. India became known as a “global baby factory.”

Sneha Banerjee, an assistant professor at the University of Hyderabad in India, who extensively studied India’s reproductive industry, says the first moves to curb this industry began after a Japanese couple had a baby via a surrogate and an egg donor. The couple divorced before the baby was born, and the Indian Supreme Court had to rule on who the baby’s legal guardian was. “That was the first time that the current government took notice of this issue,” Banerjee says.

The new Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act says a woman can donate her eggs only once and only to one other couple. She must be between 23 and 35 years old, must have been married at least once and must have a child age 3 or older.

But those tight restrictions have constrained supply at a time when demand is surging in India. Indian women are waiting longer to have children, when they’re less fertile.

And “the harsh realities of India [are] that we are a highly unequal society — there are a lot of poor people,” says Prabha Kotiswaran, a professor of law and social justice at King’s College London. She studies the fertility industry’s impacts on women. “There’s a lot of need,” she says, and women are bearing the brunt. “In that context, if you bring about a law that essentially shuts down a certain sector, it may be well-intentioned, but it is bound to have unintended consequences.”

The workings of the black market

Kotiswaran says soon after the law was implemented, she found that “there was a vibrant market in paid egg donation.”

The black market for human eggs exists in India because there’s no central registration of women who have donated their eggs. Women are “traveling from one city to the other, one state to the other,” says Dr. Duru Shah, the scientific director of an upscale Mumbai clinic. She also formerly served as the president of the Federation of Obstetric and Gynaecological Societies of India. “If an egg donor comes and tells me, ‘I haven’t donated anywhere,’ how do I know? I don’t know.”

H, who sells her eggs to survive, says most clinics don’t even look hard at the IDs of women whose eggs they’ve commissioned. If they want your eggs, she says, “they’ll find a way.”

H says she uses two fake IDs that list her as being under 30 because she’s afraid of aging out of the business. H is Muslim, but when needed, she passes herself off as a recent convert to Hinduism. That’s because clinic directors say some couples request eggs from a woman whose faith matches theirs.

And despite the law saying women should be stimulated to produce only around seven eggs at one time, H says she’s routinely stimulated to produce around two dozen eggs.

A critic of the new laws, Dr. Aniruddha Malpani, the co-director of a Mumbai fertility clinic, says there’s a strong commercial incentive for fertility clinics to stimulate women to produce more eggs: the more eggs a clinic can harvest, the more couples it can treat from just one woman it has paid. 

Critics say there’s not enough oversight of this industry in India, where more than 6,800 fertility clinics operate but just over 2,500 have been registered since the new laws came into place.

Recruiting for egg donation online

When clinics need eggs for their patients, they often work through intermediaries, known as assisted reproductive technology (ART) banks, which according to the new laws, are meant to screen women for egg donation. The ART banks, as they are known, rely on people known as agents.

Like Ruby, 34. She asked that we use only her first name — her work isn’t legal. She says in a month, she gets about a dozen requests over WhatsApp for women’s eggs, like for example, “a clinic seeking a woman with an O-positive blood type, tall and pale.” She finds recruits through her networks and social media advertisements. Ruby gets paid a lump sum for each referral. She takes a cut of between $50 and $100 and then passes the rest on to the woman whose eggs have been harvested.

Critics say that the indirect chain allows fertility clinics to claim they are not paying women for eggs.

Ruby says her recruits are mostly poor. Many of them have alcoholic husbands. “Others lost their husbands. Some have financial difficulties.”

Why they risk breaking the law

Thirty-four-year-old Abirami lives in a slum in the southern city of Chennai. Like all the other women interviewed for this story, she and her friends asked to use only their first names, because they don’t want to risk getting in trouble.

She and her girlfriends walk us through their homes: each a tiny room in a row of tiny rooms down a tight alleyway, the interiors painted blues and purples. We meet Manimeghalay, who sold her eggs to pay her kid’s school fees. Anju, who sold her eggs to pay her son’s medical bill. Alamelu, who used the money to pay for her alcoholic husband’s funeral — and then, to fix a leaking roof.

Abirami assembles plastic toy guns for about $3 a day. Twice, Abirami says, she sold her eggs for about $300 to pay rent and feed her two daughters.

Abirami says she first heard about selling eggs from her neighbor while standing in line at a water pump. “Tell me where I can go and do it,” she pleaded.

When she told her husband, he accused her of being promiscuous — there’s a perception in India that egg retrieval is related to sex work. “He doesn’t understand the difference between thick and thin,” Abirami sniffed.

“The moment my husband left for work,” Abirami recalls, she and her neighbor sneaked out to a fertility clinic by bus. “I am illiterate,” Abirami explains, so she counted the stops to remember the route. It was “seven stops away.”

Abirami says that in the fertility clinic, she was hustled into a room where a nurse filled a form and told her to sign it with her thumbprint. Days later, she was being stimulated with hormones to produce more eggs.

Abirami says for her, the process was painful. “I thought the nausea would kill me,” she says. Her stomach swelled, which can be a sign she was overstimulated. Despite the pain, she sold her eggs again, two years later.

Vrinda Marwah, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of South Florida, investigated India’s fertility industry and says the new laws have made the lives of vulnerable Indian women even more precarious.

“You’ve told yourself you’ve done something, but actually you’ve only made it worse,” she says, referring to the legislators who formulated this law. “You’ve created a black market, which means the people participating in it have no protections — they have no bargaining power. If something goes wrong, they’re already doing something criminal, something illegal. So who are they going to turn to for help?”

A troubling incident

H, who sells her eggs to survive, says she couldn’t ask anyone for help when two years ago, a male agent sent her to a hospital to have her eggs extracted — and things did not go well.

H says she emerged from the anesthesia with swollen eyes, cuts near her lip and welts on her back, and she was wearing a diaper. H didn’t report the incident. She was scared she’d get in trouble for selling her eggs.

H says she fled the hospital as soon as she could. “If that man,” she says, referring to the agent, “did something to me, God will punish him.”

And in September, H claims an agent stiffed her out of money for an egg retrieval conducted at a major Indian fertility clinic, Akanksha Hospital.

H says she called the hospital to plead for payment. “We paid the agent,” she recalls a woman at the hospital telling her. “This is between you and the agent.”

Dr. Nayana Patel of Akanksha Hospital did not comment on that specific incident but said in an emailed statement that they obtain donor eggs from ART banks and are “in full compliance.” Patel wrote: “all payments are made directly to the ART banks in accordance with the specified law, and therefore maintain full compliance.”

H, meanwhile, is now late paying rent. To make up for lost income, she’s taking drugs to speed up her next period, so she can be stimulated again to produce more eggs.

Luring girls to produce eggs for sale

Amid the demand for eggs, a lawyer for a teenager says that when she was 13 years old, she was lured into selling her eggs to a branch of one of India’s largest fertility clinic franchises, Nova IVF Fertility. That took place in the northern Indian city of Varanasi, and the girl’s family filed a complaint with police.

The teenager calls the woman “auntie,” a sign of respect to an elder in South Asia. And auntie got the teenager a fake ID and told her to dress like she was older. The teen smeared vermilion powder on her hair parting and put rings on her toes — in India, these are signs of a married woman.

With that, a contracting company signed off on the teenager having her eggs harvested and directed her to Nova IVF Fertility. For the next 10 days, the teenager skipped school to be stimulated with hormones and have her eggs extracted.

The teenager’s lawyer, Krishna Gopal, says he believes other minors are being lured into having their eggs harvested but says families have no incentive to come forward.

“The big people have not been touched,” he says. Gopal says Nova IVF Fertility hasn’t faced any punishment, including the doctor who extracted the teenager’s eggs. “No action has been taken against them.”

Nova IVF Fertility said in an emailed statement that the teenager was screened by a separate company that signed off on her having her eggs harvested — and that they had no way of knowing the teenager’s real age.

Can the black market be curbed?

Kotiswaran, the law professor at King’s College London, says the best way to curb the black market for human eggs is to legally compensate the women who provide them — not to pay for their eggs but for the labor involved in generating those eggs and having them extracted.

With the additional exception of surrogates, everyone else in the for-profit fertility industry, she says, is paid for their work. “This is a sector that’s generating so much profit,” she says, but “without the women, the sector wouldn’t exist,” she says. “We allow every stakeholder in the sector to make as much money as they want off the women’s bodies, but then you don’t want to pay the women themselves. So that is my fundamental problem.”

Preparing to sell eggs once more

Weeks later, we again meet H.

She’s bloated. Nauseous. Struggling to breathe. Her ailments suggest signs she was overstimulated to produce eggs — very rarely, that can be fatal. She tells us in a downtown Mumbai café, “I know this will kill me, but we’ll all die someday, right?”

Discussing her death is as casual for H as talking about the black eye she’s nursing. Her boyfriend had punched her a few days before. It’s nothing, H insists. “I bruise easily.”

What comforts her, she says, is thinking about her children, her 11-year-old-daughter and 13-year-old son. The ones she birthed herself. They’re being raised by her ex-husband.

She says that whenever she can, she gives them money. “They say I don’t have to, but my heart doesn’t listen,” she says. “After all, I am a mother.”

She pushes back her chair to leave. She’s got word that she’ll be able to see them if she can leg it across town in half an hour.

Diaa Hadid and Shweta Desai reported this story from Mumbra, Mumbai, Chennai and Varanasi, India. Anupama Chandrasekaran contributed reporting from Chennai.